When Can Employers Request Medical Documentation?

Publication
Inside HR
FMLA
Read time: 4 mins

Heard it on the Hotline

One of the most common questions we receive through the HR Hotline is whether an employer can require medical documentation to support an employee’s request for leave or a workplace accommodation. The answer depends on the type of leave or accommodation requested and the applicable laws. The Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA) each have different requirements and limitations regarding medical documentation.

Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA)

Under the FMLA, employers may generally require an employee to provide medical certification when initially requesting leave for their own serious health condition or to care for a covered family member. An exception applies to a father requesting leave to bond with a newborn child, as medical certification is not required for bonding leave.

Once an employer receives an initial certification, it generally may not request recertification more frequently than every six months in connection with an absence. However, there are circumstances when an employer may request updated documentation sooner, including:

  • Expiration of the original certification: If the period of leave identified in the certification has ended and the employee continues to need leave, the employer may request a new certification.
  • Significant changes in the employee’s absence: If the employee’s absences substantially exceed the frequency or duration identified in the original certification, the employer may request recertification.
  • Changed circumstances: If the circumstances described in the original certification have changed significantly, the employer may have grounds to request recertification.

The U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) provides optional forms employers may use to obtain medical certification and other documentation related to FMLA leave.

Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

Under the ADA, employers may request medical documentation when an employee’s disability or need for an accommodation is not obvious or already known. The purpose of the documentation is to establish that the employee has a disability under the ADA and that the requested accommodation is related to the disability.

Employers should not ask employees or their healthcare providers to disclose a specific diagnosis. Instead, requests for documentation should be limited to information necessary to understand the employee’s functional limitations and accommodation needs.

Appropriate documentation may include information about the nature, severity, and expected duration of the impairment, as well as the major life activities affected and how the requested accommodation would address the employee’s limitations.

Unlike the FMLA, there is no government-provided medical certification form specifically for ADA accommodation requests. However, MRA has developed a sample medical documentation form that members can customize and use within their organizations.

Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA)

The PWFA places additional limitations on when employers may request medical documentation to support an accommodation request. Generally, employers cannot require documentation when the employee’s need for an accommodation is obvious or when the request involves a simple modification that does not warrant medical support.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) identifies the following as examples of accommodations that generally should not require supporting medical documentation:

  • Allowing an employee to carry water and drink as needed.
  • Providing additional restroom breaks.
  • Allowing additional breaks for snacks.
  • Providing additional breaks for stretching.
  • Allowing an employee to sit or stand as needed.

For accommodation requests beyond these simple modifications, an employer may request limited medical documentation when appropriate. The documentation should be sufficient to establish that the employee has a physical or mental condition related to pregnancy, childbirth, or a related medical condition and that a workplace adjustment is needed because of that condition.

The federal government has not developed a standard medical documentation form specifically for PWFA accommodation requests. Employers should carefully review any forms they use to ensure the questions are appropriate, narrowly tailored, and do not request information prohibited under the PWFA.

The Bottom Line

Although employers may request medical documentation in certain circumstances, the rules do not apply equally to every type of leave or accommodation. Before requesting documentation, employers should identify which law applies, determine whether documentation is permitted, and ensure that any questions are limited to the information necessary to evaluate the request.

When in doubt, take a step back before sending a medical documentation form. Asking for too much information can create compliance concerns, just as failing to obtain appropriate documentation can create challenges for employers.